Monday, July 14, 2008

Workshop showcases gravestone restoration

Article Date: Monday, July 14, 2008

EJ Hersom/Staff photographer Jonathan Appell explains how gravestones are made during a gravestone restoration workshop Saturday in Portsmouth.

PORTSMOUTH — The Ports-mouth Cemetery Committee held a gravestone restoration workshop Saturday, drawing about 20 people.

The workshop covered restoration techniques explained by professional gravestone conservator and monument mason Jonathan Appell of Connecticut.

He spent the afternoon with attendees at the North Cemetery going over proper gravestone cleaning techniques, teaching them how to reset a leaning stone before it snaps and how to handle broken gravestones.

Jen Marcelais, Portsmouth Cemetery Committee member, said this is the first workshop of its kind the committee has put together.

"I think it was a good idea to get a professional out here to let us know the dos and don'ts of keeping up with the grave sites," she said. "We have people here who are part of cemetery committees in different towns and those who are just interested in this topic."

Appell, who owns New England Cemetery Services, has worked at many sites across the region.

One of the most common questions he gets asked about gravestone restoration is what to do when a stone has begun to deteriorate.

"Many people think carvings on a grave stone can simply be redone once they have worn away or deteriorated," he said. "In fact, that is probably the worst thing you can do. It won't last, and will just open up the pores and make things worse."

He said many gravestones are sealed after they have been carved, and recarving an engraved message will break the seal and allow the elements to wear away the stone faster than it normally would.

During the workshop, he demonstrated how to reset a stone after it has broken off at the base and how to stand up stones that have been leaning and are in danger of breaking.

"It is really important to have the right kind of tools for these restorations and know what type of stone you are working with," he said. "Besides, some of these things are really heavy."

Another common question is about how to clean a gravestone, Appell said.

"Sometimes cleaning the stone may not be an option without making it look worse," he said. "You need to be extremely gentle, or you might remove some of the stone in the cleaning process."

He suggests examining the stone before doing anything to see if it's cleanable. If the stone shows signs of flaking, chipping, scaling or other forms of deterioration, cleaning the stone will do more harm than good.

Appell's website is For more information on the Portsmouth Cemetery Committee, call 436-5096 or visit their website at

Copyright © 2008 Geo. J. Foster Company.

Sunday, June 15, 2008

City's historic cemetery is in grave condition, Aim is to restore 17th-century Revere site (Revere, Massachusetts)

Revere official Nicholas Bua at the city’s historic Rumney Marsh Burial Ground.
Revere official Nicholas Bua at the city’s historic Rumney Marsh Burial Ground. (Globe Staff Photo / Dina Rudick)

By Katheleen Conti Globe Staff / January 3, 2008

When most people consider Revere's historical treasures, they might think first of Revere Beach and its pride in being "America's first public beach."

But few are aware that Revere's only burial ground, listed in the National Register of Historic Places, is more than 300 years old and is the final resting place of its early residents and war veterans.

Last Memorial Day, Nicholas Bua, the city's director of Veteran Services, and City Councilor Ira Novoselsky walked among the cracked, broken, and toppled headstones, making their way past the large trees with overgrown roots to place American flags on the graves of Revolutionary War and Civil War veterans.

They were appalled at what they saw.

"I said to Ira, 'This is in deplorable condition,' " Bua said. "It's neglect. It's just out of the way, out of sight, out of mind. . . . It's heartbreaking to see these graves and the condition of the cemetery."

The city has not paid much attention to the Olde Rumney Marsh Burial Ground, which is in a residential neighborhood on Butler Street, Novoselsky said.

"All the city is doing is cutting the grass, but the trees are overgrown," Novoselsky said. "Everybody involved in it said it's a city thing, but it's not a top priority. I said, 'Well, we have to make it a top priority.' "

Bua and Novoselsky tapped Jeff Pearlman, a history buff and former Revere school teacher, and Nicholas Catinazzo, the city's public health director, to form a cemetery restoration committee about six months ago. They estimated it would cost about $100,000 for an entire makeover - removing overgrown trees, fixing the brick walkway, and repairing the stone wall and entrance gate, which is unhinged. The last time the grounds were restored was in 1975 by the Revere Historical and Cultural Commission, according to City Clerk John Henry.

The committee, along with the Revere Society for Cultural and Historic Preservation, has created a bank account to accept donations, and has been selling $5 commemorative pins to raise funds. The City Council has agreed to commit $15,000 a year for the next three years toward the restoration. But as soon as the council vote was taken, concerns arose about the feasibility of such a commitment, given a warning to Mayor Thomas G. Ambrosino from local lawmakers that the city might not get much local aid from the state in the next fiscal year.

"It would be my goal to put it in the budget, but next fiscal year is the one I'm most worried about now," Ambrosino said. "If we get the same amount in aid as we did this year, or less, it'll be a disaster. Layoffs would be likely."

City Councilor George Rotondo, who voted in favor of the $15,000 annual appropriation, said he is not optimistic that the city will come through.

"We're coming on the heels of what appears to me to be a deficit next year, so to commit $15,000 a year seems like a lot," Rotondo said. "I feel comfortable doing it for the first year, but after that, we need to look at private sources. I'm in favor of $15,000 for this year, but not after that."

Novoselsky said Ambrosino's "got to be able to finagle a bagel and work things out," because "$15,000 isn't a lot of money." Still, the restoration committee is preparing for a major fund-raising effort. It has secured a $5,000 grant from Shore Educational Collaborative for the production of a promotional film telling the history of the city's only cemetery.

"I hate to say it, and, as a historian, it makes me angry, there just aren't enough people that are knowledgeable that we even have the Rumney Marsh Burial Grounds," Pearlman said. "It's not just one of the first, but [it's] the only one within the confines of the city of Revere. The kids and parents have no idea. Revere Beach takes up all the attention."

From 1624 to 1738, the village of Rumney Marsh was part of Boston. In 1690, in the midst of a smallpox breakout, Boston selectmen ordered that "all persons dying at Rumney Marsh, and parts adjacent, of small-pox" be buried in that area instead of being carried south through Boston, creating a hazard to residents there, according to research done by Henry. It wasn't until 1743 that Chelsea adopted what would become the Rumney Marsh Burial Ground. In 1871, North Chelsea, which included the burial ground, adopted the name of Revere.

Many of the local Revolutionary War veterans and the city's first residents buried there have names familiar to most area residents, since many streets and neighborhoods in Chelsea, Revere, and Winthrop are named for them. Of the close to 150 people buried there, the most noted would be Deane Winthrop, son of John Winthrop, first governor of the Massachusetts Bay Colony. Also buried are seven Colonial Wars (1675-1763) veterans, 20 Revolutionary War veterans, four veterans of the War of 1812, and 13 Civil War veterans, according to research prepared by Henry. Along the Butler Street wall, an estimated 16 slaves and former slaves are buried.

The oldest gravestone in the burial ground marks the resting place of Mary Smith, who died in 1693, while the latest burial was that of Lewis L. Bullard in 1929. According to Henry's research, Rumney Marsh is the fourth-oldest burial ground in Suffolk County, which is why Catinazzo said the city needs to preserve it as local history.

"Kids go in there at night, drinking, doing some vandalism," Catinazzo said. "We want to see it done right. It's amazing when you put this out, people just think it's a cemetery, but when they see the history, they get excited."

more stories like this

Pearlman said the project is not about tourism dollars but about preserving the history of Revere for future generations. And, as for why the cemetery was neglected for so long, he said, "That's the $100,000 question."

Donations for the restoration of the burial ground may be sent to The Rumney Marsh Burial Ground Restoration Committee, in care of East Boston Savings Bank, 575 Broadway, Revere 02151.

Among those buried

  • Deane Winthrop, son of John Winthrop, who was the first governor of Massachusetts Bay Colony. The seaside town is named for Deane Winthrop.

  • Mary Smith, oldest recorded remains at the Rumney Marsh Burial Ground. Smith died in 1693 and was initially buried under or near the site of the Church of Christ at Carey Avenue and Beach and Eustis streets. In 1910, the remains of many early settlers, including Smith, were removed from the church site and reburied at Rumney Marsh.

  • The Rev. Thomas Cheever, whose son, Joshua, deeded in his will the Rumney Marsh Burial Ground to the town of Chelsea in 1751. That part of Chelsea is now Revere.

  • Deacon John Sale, a delegate to the Provincial Congress and a representative to the Massachusetts General Court. His farm, Beachmont, played an important role in the first naval battle of the Revolutionary War, known as the Battle of Chelsea Creek, in 1775.

  • Lieutenant Thomas Pratt, who owned a farm once belonging to the estate of Sir Henry Vane, a Massachusetts governor. In 1734, at his own expense, Pratt built a tidewater mill, where the famous Slade's Spice Mill would later stand. The Prattville section of Chelsea is named for him.

  • Samuel Sprague, who led three companies of Minutemen during the Revolution.

  • The Rev. Phillips Payson, known as the "fighting parson," who actively participated in the Battle of Lexington in 1775.
SOURCE: The Rumney Marsh Burial Ground Renovation Committee

Katheleen Conti can be reached at
© 2008 NY Times Co. / The Boston Globe

View this burying ground at

Sunday, May 11, 2008

New Amesbury Photos: Salisbury Plains and Old Corner Cemetery

Today I stopped by to reshoot Salisbury Plains Cemetery. It's been a few years since my last visit so I thought I'd update the photos and check out the condition. It hasn't improved much, there are still lots of broken stones and some landscaping to be done. But there were some interesting replacement markers that had been placed since my last visit. They were placed next to the original stones for a few of the early Clough family members and each had carvings that reflected the style of the carvers at the time of their death. On the back of each was a small plaque that noted the people whom the gravestones were donated in memory of on behalf of their family. I thought it was a great concept, both for helping to restore the cemetery and give a lasting gift in memory of a lover of genealogy who has passed on. View all the latest and the old photos at

I also stopped by the Old Corner Cemetery for the first time. It was established in 1772 and has many interesting gravestones. But it's in horrible shape. The grounds are littered with broken stones. Some are stacked up in piles. But it's filled with the old ancestors of Amesbury along with some unique carvings and Revolutionary War veterans. View all photos at

Last weekend I came across the Bridge St. Cemetery in West Newbury, MA. I took some photos but the older gravestones were shadowed so I'll have to go back another day. They're at